PROC-02
PROC
P0
How we measure success
We measure success with two tools, and we refuse a third kind of number. Search Console answers search visibility with clicks and impressions. GA4 answers behavior and conversion with sessions and conversions. We refuse vanity counts, and we refuse average position as a headline.
What This Is
We measure success with two tools, and we refuse a third kind of number. Search Console answers search visibility with clicks and impressions. GA4 answers behavior and conversion with sessions and conversions. We refuse vanity counts, and we refuse average position as a headline.
The monthly report is sent on the 7th, with data through the end of the prior month, by email. It contains GSC clicks and impressions, GA4 sessions, conversions, keyword rankings, work completed, and the next month plan.
Before you check
The site is verified in Search Console.
GA4 is installed and collecting data.
You are comparing whole periods, not single days. The last 3 days of GSC are incomplete.
If any of these is false, fix it before running the tree.
Diagnostic tree
Run the checks in order.
Check 1. Is the number a refused metric?
How: check the number against the refuse list. Refused metrics are average position as a headline, and vanity counts such as raw pageviews alone, raw users, or social shares.
Why: these numbers move without meaning anything for revenue or visibility. We refuse to report them as the headline.
If the number is a refused metric, go to Resolution B. If the number is not a refused metric, go to Check 2.
Check 2. Is the question about search visibility?
How: restate the question. If it asks whether we are more visible, it is a visibility question. If it asks what people did, it is a behavior or conversion question.
Why: visibility questions are answered by GSC, not GA4. Mixing the two is the root of “the numbers don’t match.”
If it is a visibility question, go to Check 3. If it is a behavior or conversion question, go to Check 4.
Check 3. Which GSC number answers it?
How: in Search Console, Performance, then Search results. Read clicks, impressions, and position.
Why: clicks and impressions are real visibility signals. Average position blends every query into one number, so it hides which queries moved.
If the number is clicks or impressions, go to Resolution A. If the number is average position, go to Resolution B.
Check 4. Which GA4 number answers it?
How: in GA4, Reports, then Acquisition, then Traffic acquisition for sessions. Then Engagement, then Conversions for conversions.
Why: sessions measure visits. Conversions measure outcomes. Pageviews alone is a vanity count.
If the number is sessions or conversions, go to Resolution A. If the number is a vanity count, go to Resolution B.
Resolutions
Resolution | Condition | Action |
|---|---|---|
A. Real metric | The number answers the question asked | Report it, with the period and the tool named |
B. Refused metric | The number is a vanity count or average position as a headline | Refuse it. Swap in clicks, impressions, sessions, or conversions |
C. Monthly report | It is time to report | Send on the 7th, data through end of prior month, by email |
Resolution C runs regardless of A or B. The report is how every metric, real or refused, gets published. Its contents are fixed: GSC clicks and impressions, GA4 sessions, conversions, keyword rankings, work completed, and the next month plan.
When to escalate
Escalate when all are true.
The client wants average position or a vanity count as the headline metric.
We have refused once.
The client still wants it, and the number would drive a decision.
Everything else closes in the table above.
Primary sources
Related articles
Last verified
·
Owner
Mahesh